1 October. The deadline passed a week ago, and I am still reading four pages the European Commission published in August. The most important words in them are not in the text. They sit in the header, in brackets: without an impact assessment.
The document is the call for evidence on revising the EIT Regulation, published on 12 August with six weeks for feedback, most of them in the summer holidays.¹ For some time I have been developing a way of reading such documents backwards. I call it functional consultation analysis: you list what an instrument asserts, what it asks and what it leaves out, and then ask what each of those choices prepares.² The method rests on a simple observation. Reading it back to front – A questionnaire tells you what an institution wants to measure. A call for evidence is a claim with a question attached.
Here the claim begins with those brackets. Without an impact assessment there is no structured comparison of options and no review by the Commission’s Regulatory Scrutiny Board. The justification is telling. The Commission relies on the impact assessment for the future European Competitiveness Fund, which covered Horizon Europe “and, by extension, the EIT”.¹ An institute with its own regulation and its own board was assessed as an appendix.
The paper names five problems, and two of them carry the weight. The first is a sentence filed, of all places, under “complexity”. It insists that full compliance by the Knowledge and Innovation Communities with the EU’s financial and ethical rules “remains essential”, together with “their integration under the Horizon work programme and comitology” and stronger oversight by the EIT.¹ Under a heading about simplification, it adds control. Comitology is the procedure through which member states shape the work programme in committee. If the KICs’ activities are set there, the KICs no longer decide what they do by themselves.
The second is the sharpest line in the document. The KICs have built ecosystems that “may require EU support”, it concedes, but “self-sustainability is one of the conditions for supporting KICs in the first place”.¹ Read backwards, that is not a reminder. It lays the legal ground for ending support to communities that have not learned to pay their own way.
The objectives follow. The EIT is to be “integrated into the innovation ecosystems part of Horizon Europe”, its communities aligned with the thematic windows of the Competitiveness Fund, their work focused “on early-stage innovation”. Education becomes entrepreneurial education. Four of the five performance indicators measure commercial results; regional convergence, promised three times, is measured by none of them. And the first of the four questions asks for the features of the EIT “common to all or most of its KICs” — an invitation to describe a standard model rather than a distinctive one. Nowhere is anyone asked whether the KICs should be folded into comitology at all. The deepest change in the paper is the one put to nobody.
What it leaves out
No KIC is named, nor any of their themes. The word “culture” appears once, in “cultural gaps between academia and business”, which means company culture rather than the cultural and creative industries. There are no figures at all, and nothing on the partnership agreements still running. Silence in four pages is a choice. It keeps every option open and gives no community a reason to mobilise early.
So is this the beginning of the end? I don’t think the paper abolishes the KICs. It does something quieter. It keeps the name and removes most of what made a KIC a KIC: a long-term partnership with the freedom to set its own agenda. What remains is an early-stage delivery channel inside a work programme, steered in committee and continued only if it pays for itself. It is less a felling than a pruning so hard that the tree may not come back. If that reading holds, this is the beginning of the end of the KIC as an institution, even if the acronym survives.
The pruning did not start with this paper. In recent years, those of us working inside a KIC watched the money move. More of it was to flow out as cascade funding — open calls and sub-grants to start-ups and projects — and less was to be spent on the slow work of building an ecosystem: bringing people together, finding the studio that ought to meet the university down the road. Ecosystem building was to be kept to a minimum. For a long time that was said in corridors rather than plenaries; before and after this summer, it was presented at partner meetings, most recently on 24 September.³ Cascade funding is easy to count. Relationships are not. But a KIC that only passes grants on does what the European Innovation Council and the Commission’s own programmes already do, and do with lower overheads. Once that is all it does, the paper’s complaint about “overlap” answers itself.
I should be honest about the method’s limits. Reading backwards produces strong inferences, not facts, and the method paper itself warns against over-interpretation. There is a second risk it names, and it applies to me: the conflict of roles when the analyst is also an advocate.² The Commission’s proposal, due before the end of the year, may prove me wrong.
Some of what the paper wants is also not unreasonable. Compliance with the rules for public money is not an imposition but the price of spending it. Some communities have taken a long time to stand on their own feet, and a leaner, more accountable EIT may be what carries it through a hard budget negotiation.
What troubles me is less the direction than the method, and who carries the cost. Self-sustainability is a function of time and of the sector you work in. A community only a few years old, working with micro-firms and freelancers, will reach its targets more slowly than one in energy or health. EIT Culture & Creativity is one of the youngest KICs and works in exactly such a sector. A rule that treats all communities alike is not neutral when they are not alike.
The paper also contradicts itself, which may be the most useful thing about it. It promises the KICs “greater continuity” and, a few lines earlier, the flexibility to follow “changing EU priorities” and “unforeseen events”.¹ Both can only be true if someone separates a protected core from a share that can move. That line has not been drawn yet.
…and now? The argument moves to Parliament and Council once the proposal is out. The questions worth taking there are the ones the paper never asked. Should the KICs be steered in committee at all? And how long should a young community have before it must stand on its own?
I helped to build one of these communities. I would like to know whether it was built to last, or only to be counted.
Notes
- European Commission, Call for evidence for an initiative (without an impact assessment), “Revision of the EIT Regulation and of the Strategic Innovation Agenda”, Ref. Ares(2026)7822228, 12 August 2026, DG EAC; feedback period 12 August–23 September 2026, Have your say. All quoted passages are taken verbatim from this document.
- Gerin Trautenberger, Functional Consultation Analysis: Inferring Policy Trajectories from the Design of Consultation Instruments, working paper, method section (September 2026, unpublished). The method treats consultation instruments as objects of analysis in their own right and combines document analysis, speech act theory, post-structuralist policy analysis and survey methodology; the working term in practice is “reverse analytics”. The reading in this essay is the author’s interpretation, not a statement of the Commission’s position.
- EIT Culture & Creativity partner meeting, 24 September 2026.
Disclosure: The author led the EIT Culture & Creativity Co-Location Centre for South East Europe & Alps until April 2026. Kreativwirtschaft Austria, which he chairs, is a member of EIT Culture & Creativity.