Field Notes

Essay 21 October 2026 5 min read

On pricing ideas by the hour

„The better you get, the less you earn per idea. I told a room of Austrian creatives to stop billing by the hour – and I’m still arguing with myself.“

Floral still life by Hans Bollongier, 1639: striped tulips, roses and anemones in a glass vase
Hans Bollongier, Floral Still Life, 1639 — painted two years after the Dutch tulip market collapsed. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam. Public domain.

On a Thursday morning in October I had five minutes on a Zoom call and one slide I cared about. The session was called “And where does the money come from?”, part of a knowledge-transfer series run by Kreativwirtschaft Austria. My slide read: We sell hours. Our clients buy results. The rest was meant to explain why that gap costs us money.

The argument is simple enough to fit on a slide. The hourly rate rewards the wrong thing. A logo that takes three hours can be worth more to a start-up than a wayfinding system an office spends three months on.¹ Experience makes you faster, and speed makes you cheaper. The better you get, the less you earn per idea.

Value-based pricing turns the question round. It sets the price by what the work is worth to the client, not by the effort that went into it.² Few companies do. Averaged across published studies, only about 17 per cent of companies price on customer value; 44 per cent follow the competition and 37 per cent add a margin to their costs. The obstacles are mundane: value is hard to measure, and harder still to explain.³

I find that encouraging, oddly. Measuring and explaining are things creative people are good at.

What the client actually asked for

There is a second reason I thought the provocation would land. Creative work is innovation work for other industries. A new pack lifts sales, a redesigned service cuts the cost of handling complaints, a platform opens a market. Austria’s latest creative industries report describes the sector, plainly, as an innovation driver that carries new technology into many others.⁴ A McKinsey study of 300 listed companies found that those in the top quartile for design grew revenue 32 percentage points faster than their industry over five years — a correlation, not a proof, but not nothing either.⁵

And clients have told us, in so many words, what they want. When the sixth Austrian creative industries report looked at the demand side, client firms said they wished for “understanding of their business model and their business methods”, and expected “a high level of advisory competence” from the people they hired.⁶ Read that again with pricing in mind. Our clients are asking us to understand how they make money. That is exactly what you need to know before you can put a price on what an idea is worth to them.

So the step seemed obvious. If our work changes a number the client cares about, agree the number beforehand and take a share of the change. Companies set targets all the time. Nobody measures a sales team by the hours it spent on the phone, and no managing director hands the board a timesheet. Only in our trade do both sides accept that time is the yardstick.

Where it gets harder

Then I started arguing with myself, which is the part I want to be honest about.

Three in four Austrian creative firms are one-person businesses, against just over half in the economy as a whole.⁸ A share of next year’s growth is a fine idea if you have the cash to wait for it. For someone working alone it is the client’s business risk, moved onto the smallest balance sheet in the deal.

The evidence from advertising is not kind either. When the American advertisers’ association surveyed its members in 2017, the use of performance incentives in agency contracts had fallen sharply for the first time in the survey’s fifty years, and only 7 per cent paid on value.⁹ The people who have tried this at scale seem to be backing away from it, at least partly.

Attribution is the other problem. Did sales rise because of the new design, the price cut or a warm spring? The client holds the data; we usually do not. And once a number becomes the target, it starts to bend. Economists have a name for this, after Charles Goodhart: when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.¹⁰ A brand can hit its conversion figure and quietly lose what made it worth buying from.

None of this kills the idea, I think, but it does change its shape. A fee that covers the cost of the work, plus a share tied to a target both sides can actually measure, looks more defensible to me than the pure version.It is less exciting to say on stage.

…and now?

I ended the session with a question rather than an answer: which number would your most important client sign, and would you tie your fee to it? I do not know how most of the people listening would answer, and that is the uncomfortable bit. There is, as far as I can find, no recent data on how Austrian creative firms actually set their prices. We have opinions, and a ten-year-old survey of what clients want.

We are still paid for the digging. Some of us would like to be paid for what grows. Before we ask for that, it might be worth finding out how many of us could say, with a straight face, what grew from their last idea.

„We bill for the digging. Our clients pay for what grows.
A provocation about pricing ideas – and the doubts that came with it.“

Notes

  1. Illustrative example, not a case study. The critique of billable hours and utilisation rates as a management measure is set out in Baker (2011).
  2. Definition after Hinterhuber (2008); applied to professional service firms in Baker (2011).
  3. Hinterhuber (2008), average of published studies 1983–2006. These figures are more than twenty years old; no comparable survey for the creative industries exists.
  4. Kreativwirtschaft Austria (2026), Kreativwirtschaftsbericht Österreich 2026, p. 8.
  5. Sheppard et al. (2018), The business value of design, McKinsey Quarterly. 300 listed companies, five years; top quartile on the McKinsey Design Index vs. industry peers. Correlation, not causation.
  6. creativ wirtschaft austria (2015), Sechster Österreichischer Kreativwirtschaftsbericht, summary, p. 32. Data: creative industries survey 2014 (IHS/ZEW). Quotations translated from the German by the author.
  7. The author’s argument, put as a provocation; not based on survey data.
  8. Kreativwirtschaft Austria (2026), p. 23: 76 per cent of creative enterprises are one-person businesses, against 56 per cent across the economy (2023 data).
  9. Association of National Advertisers (2017), Trends in Agency Compensation, press release.
  10. Goodhart (1975); the familiar wording is Strathern’s (1997).

Sources

  • Association of National Advertisers (2017): ANA Study Finds Agency Compensation Models Shifting Away From Fees and Incentives. https://www.ana.net/content/show/id/pr-2017-compensation-models
  • Baker, R. J. (2011): Implementing Value Pricing: A Radical Business Model for Professional Firms. Hoboken: Wiley.
  • creativ wirtschaft austria (2015): Sechster Österreichischer Kreativwirtschaftsbericht. Kurzfassung. https://www.kreativwirtschaft.at/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/KWB6-Kurzfassung-D.pdf
  • Goodhart, C. (1975): Problems of Monetary Management: The UK Experience. Papers in Monetary Economics, Vol. 1. Sydney: Reserve Bank of Australia.
  • Hinterhuber, A. (2008): Customer value-based pricing strategies: why companies resist. Journal of Business Strategy 29(4).
  • Kreativwirtschaft Austria (2026): Kreativwirtschaftsbericht Österreich 2026. https://forschungsnetzwerk.ams.at/dam/jcr:b6cfc496-fa80-4670-bccf-7e3c53e4e194/Kreativwirtschaftsbericht_Oesterreich_2026.pdf
  • Sheppard, B., Sarrazin, H., Kouyoumjian, G., Dore, F. (2018): The business value of design. McKinsey Quarterly. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/growth-marketing-and-sales/our-insights/the-business-value-of-design
  • Strathern, M. (1997): ‘Improving ratings’: audit in the British University system. European Review 5(3), 305–321.